Black Lotus Alpha Magic: The Gathering

A regular Alpha booster pack cost $2.45 in 1993. Inside one of those packs might have been a Black Lotus - a card that costs zero mana to play, produces three mana of any color when sacrificed, and breaks the fundamental economics of Magic: The Gathering so thoroughly that it was restricted almost immediately. Only about 1,100 Alpha Black Lotuses were ever printed. In 2024, a CGC Pristine 10 sold for $3,000,000 - making it the most expensive trading card ever sold.

Quick Value Summary


Item	Black Lotus - Alpha Edition (Magic: The Gathering)
Year	1993
Category	Trading Cards - Magic: The Gathering
Set	Alpha (Limited Edition)
Publisher	Wizards of the Coast
Condition Range
Played Condition / Lower Grades	$50,000 – $100,000
PSA/BGS 7-8	$200,000 – $500,000
PSA/BGS 9	~$500,000
PSA 10 / CGC 10	$800,000 – $3,000,000
Record Sale	$3,000,000 (CGC Pristine 10, private sale, April 2024)
Population	~1,100 Alpha copies printed
Rarity	Extremely Rare

The Story

Richard Garfield designed Magic: The Gathering in a friend's apartment. He created a game where players built custom decks from randomized booster packs - a concept that didn't exist before. Wizards of the Coast printed the first set (Alpha) in 1993 in extremely limited quantities. Nobody expected the game to explode.

Black Lotus was part of the "Power Nine" - nine cards so powerful they warped the game around them. For zero mana cost, Black Lotus gives you three mana of any color. In a game where mana is the fundamental resource, this is like starting a race with a three-lap lead. You could play cards on turn one that shouldn't appear until turn three or four. It was immediately clear that Black Lotus was broken.

Wizards of the Coast restricted it (one per deck in sanctioned play) almost immediately and eventually banned it from most formats. They never reprinted it. The Alpha print run - distinguished by its slightly more rounded corners compared to Beta - produced approximately 1,100 copies. That's it. Forever.

Artist Christopher Rush created the iconic artwork: a dark lotus flower against a blue background. Rush passed away in 2016. His single illustration became synonymous with both the game and the concept of valuable trading cards.

How to Identify It

Alpha vs. Beta vs. Unlimited

Alpha: Slightly more rounded corners than any other Magic edition. Darker ink, specific color saturation. ~1,100 copies
Beta: Slightly less rounded corners. ~3,200 copies. PSA 10 Beta: ~$615,000
Unlimited: White-bordered, mass-printed. Worth significantly less

Key Card Features

Card type: Artifact
Mana cost: 0
Text: "Adds 3 mana of any single color of your choice to your mana pool, then is discarded. Tapping this artifact can be played as an interrupt."
Artist credit: Christopher Rush
Border: Black (Alpha and Beta are black-bordered; Unlimited is white-bordered)

The Corner Test

Alpha cards have distinctly more rounded corners than Beta cards. Hold them side by side and the difference is visible. This is the quickest identification method, though grading services verify this conclusively.

Value by Grade

Grade	Value
Played / Low Grade	$50,000 – $100,000
PSA/BGS 5-6	$100,000 – $200,000
PSA/BGS 7-8	$200,000 – $500,000
PSA 9	~$500,000
PSA 10	$800,000+
CGC Pristine 10	$3,000,000

Even in played condition - shuffled into decks, handled with greasy fingers, tossed on kitchen tables - a Black Lotus is worth $50,000+. That's the power of extreme scarcity combined with cultural significance.

Authentication & Fakes

CGC, PSA, or BGS grading is mandatory for any Black Lotus transaction
Alpha corner roundness must match known genuine examples
Light test: Shine a flashlight through the card. Genuine Magic cards have a specific opacity pattern. Rebacks (peeling apart cards and combining fronts/backs from different cards) are detectable this way
High-quality counterfeits exist. The printing quality of fakes has improved dramatically. Professional grading is the only reliable authentication
Proxy cards - intentional reproductions for casual play - should never be confused with genuine copies. They're marked differently
Provenance helps at these values. A card from a known collection with documented history commands more confidence

Where to Sell

Heritage Auctions - Regular high-value Magic sales
Goldin Auctions - Growing presence in TCG market
Private sale through specialist dealers - At $500,000+, the pool of buyers is small
eBay - Viable for graded examples, but buyer pool is larger at auction houses
Card Kingdom / ChannelFireball - Major MTG dealers who buy and sell high-end singles

Not sure about your Magic cards? Upload a photo to Curio Comp for a free AI estimate. Upload a photo →

Common Questions

How much is a Black Lotus worth?

Alpha edition: $50,000 to $3,000,000 depending on grade. Beta edition: $30,000 to $615,000. Unlimited: $10,000 to $100,000. The Alpha CGC Pristine 10 record of $3,000,000 makes it the most expensive trading card ever sold.

How many Black Lotuses exist?

About 1,100 Alpha copies and roughly 3,200 Beta copies were printed. Unlimited copies are more numerous but still limited. Nobody knows exactly how many survive in any condition.

Why is it so expensive?

Three factors: extreme scarcity (~1,100 copies), game-defining power (it's the most iconic card in Magic), and cultural significance (Magic: The Gathering has millions of active players 30+ years later). Supply can never increase. Demand keeps growing.

Can I still play with a Black Lotus?

It's banned in most sanctioned formats and restricted (one copy) in Vintage. You could technically play a $3,000,000 card in a Vintage tournament. Most people use proxies.